Friday, December 21, 2012

Guns, Teachers, and Reform


If your reading this, it means you clicked the link to my blog…which means a lot considering I am not a blogger and not an expert in really anything (as I’ve explained numerous times).  I did however want to offer my opinion on the hot topic of gun control and reform.  Let me first off say that I am deeply saddened by what happened last Friday.  This act of insanity hits home for me since I have two kids, ages six and seven.  I cannot even begin to imagine what kind of pain, agony, anger, sadness, and confusion they parents must be feeling.  I commend the teachers and administrators who laid down their lives that day in an effort to save innocent children. 

Now that a week has passed, we are now looking for answers and solutions.  Social media has exploded while people take sides.  Parents are left wondering if their school is next.  Our government feels compelled to do something, anything to help prevent this tragedy from happening again.  Where do we go from here?  Some are calling for a ban on assault weapons, high capacity magazines and mental health evaluations on anyone who wants to exercise their 2nd Amendment by purchasing a gun.  Here is my take on some of these so-called solutions and then I’ll offer my own. 

First off, let’s address the war on assault weapons.  For one, I hate that rifles like the AR-15 are labeled an “assault” weapon when pistols, shotguns, and even numb chucks are just as capable of assaulting someone.  Just using the word, “assault” gives readers the impression that they are “deadlier” weapons then others.   These rifles have become the scapegoat since the popular AR-15 has been used in some of the recent massacres.   As David Kopel explains, “what some people call "assault weapons" function like every other normal firearm—they fire only one bullet each time the trigger is pressed. Unlike automatics (machine guns), they do not fire continuously as long as the trigger is held. They are "semi-automatic" because they eject the empty shell case and load the next round into the firing chamber.”   Point being is this; the shooter at Sandy Hook could have done just as much damage with just two pistols, period. 

One of the major measures being introduced, specifically by Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif,) would ban the sale, transfer, and possession of big clips, drums, or strips of more than 10 bullets.  Would limiting shooters to 10 rounds per magazine prevent mass shootings?  That’s exactly like saying limiting bar patrons to 16 ounces per beer will prevent them from driving drunk.  We all know that people will just order more 16oz beers.  It’s nonsense and is not a viable counter measure to crazed gunmen who wish to harm the innocent.  Magazines holding more than 10 rounds are not something new. They were invented decades ago and have long been standard for many handguns and rifles. Police officers carry them for the same reason that civilians do: Especially if a person is attacked by multiple assailants, there is no guarantee that a 10-round magazine will end the assault.

So what’s your solution Rich?  What would you do if you had the power to change things?  Great question and I’m glad you asked!  The first thing American’s have to start to grapple with is this: responsible people with guns are a deterrent to mentally ill people with guns.  Now I’m not saying that we arm every citizen like some are calling for.  But the facts don’t lie.  Many of these attacks take place in “gun-free zones” like schools, theaters and shopping malls.  The problem is that by the time the police arrive (who have guns), people are already wounded or dead.  But armed citizens who are on the scene save lives.  Just last week, an active shooter open fired in the Clackamas Mall in Oregon.  But when he saw a shopper, who had a handgun carry permit, draw his gun and aim it at him, the murderer committed suicide.  Mass murders that were thwarted by armed citizens happen more than we think.  Remember the Shoney's Restaurant incident in Anniston, Ala. (1991), the high school in Pearl, Miss. (1997), the middle-school dance in Edinboro, Penn. (1998), and the New Life Church in Colorado Springs, Colo. (2007), among others.

So where does that leave us?  Rich, are you saying that we should give teachers guns?  Yes, that’s exactly what I’m saying.  I saw this picture today during my social media surfing. 

This image made me feel cringe, mainly because this very scene on top actually happened last week.  But it also made me realize that teachers are incapable of effectively protecting their students from gun-wielding idiots.  They are bringing a stapler to a gun fight.  It’s just not fair. 

Real gun-free zones are a great idea in theory but they are only real if they are created by metal detectors backed up by armed guards. Pretend gun-free zones, where law-abiding adults (who pass a fingerprint-based background check and a safety training class) are still disarmed, are magnets for evildoers who know they will be able to murder at will with little threat of being fired upon.

Here’s my idea.  Offer teachers the option of taking a safety training class along with some real life scenario based instruction.  Make the districts purchase the teachers handgun of choice and allow them to carry those weapons concealed in their classrooms.  After September 11th, we offered something similar to pilots so they could defend their aircraft's and passengers.   Will this cost the states some extra money?  Yes, but after this latest school shooting, do you think it would be hard to convince parents to pay some additional fees to ensure their students have a chance to survive if God-forbid this happens again?  Not at all! 

Other measures being considered would include closing the gun show loop hole, making it illegal to sell any type of weapon at a gun show without a federal background check.  I actually agree with this piece of legislation.  As it stands today, 33 states do not restrict the selling of guns at gun shows which means buyers who purchase guns are not required to submit to the federal background checks. 

I think we have to remember that criminals don’t follow the law.  Banning the purchase of weapons like the AR-15 or high capacity magazines will NOT reduce crime or prevent mass shootings.  Evidence of this is found by looking at the federal assault-weapons ban passed in 1994 by Congress.  This so called ban focused on 18 specific firearms like certain models of the AR-15 and Ak-47.  But because of numerous loopholes and the fact that criminals still had access to virtually any weapon they wanted, the ban was ineffective at reducing crime or gun violence. 

Here’s my bottom line; rather than focusing on things that sound good, let’s focus on tangible solutions that will actually prevent and deter these acts of violence from happening again.  We can install sophisticated entry systems, close campuses, and install metal detectors but criminals will find a way around them.  Shooters who are hell-bent on murder have little respect for authority or policy.  But when confronted by passionate teachers or citizens who are not afraid to return fire in order to save the innocent lives of our children, families, friends and even strangers  might re-think their decision to attack our schools, malls, churches, and restaurants.  Taking guns away only enables the law breakers. 

As John F. Kennedy once said, “By calling attention to ‘a well regulated militia,’ ‘the security of the nation,’ and the right of each citizen ‘to keep and bear arms,’ our founding fathers recognized the essentially civilian nature of our economy… The Second Amendment still remains an important declaration of our basic civilian-military relationships in which every citizen must be ready to participate in the defense of his country. For that reason I believe the Second Amendment will always be important.”

Please comment below!  I would love to hear your ideas, comments and complaints. 

References:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323723104578185271857424036.html?mod=WSJ_article_MoreIn_Opinion

1 comment:

  1. Brilliant.

    This is a well reasoned, well supported and well written article.

    I especially like the revelation and implications of "pretend gun-free zones".

    Insightful, logical and it demonstrates original thinking.

    Anyone interested in the gun debate should read this one.

    ReplyDelete